jetsetgreen

Friday, April 17, 2009

CTRL + C, CTRL + V

I can’t stand plagiarism; it’s annoying and lazy. Not to mention that plagiarism increases the chances that I'll re-read something I've already read--which is unacceptable. I'm busy! No time to re-read! That’s why when it came to my attention that yet another person was ripping off my friend cjane, I decided to write this little post.

First of all, if you’re going to plagiarize someone, don’t make it one of the most well known people in the blogosphere—especially if your audience might have a lot of overlap with the more popular blogger.

Second of all, if you’re going to plagiarize someone, don’t, because it’s incredible stupid and you’ll always be found out.

If you don’t have anything to write about that day, your first line of defense shouldn’t be “I’m going to go and take someone else’s content.” If you’re having trouble writing, try an exercise, like writing about a topic, say, plagiarism. I’ll even give you a specific topic: What would happen if I were to rip off one of the best-known bloggers in the United States and everyone found out?

I didn’t get to see the post that she apparently copied nearly word for word, but I did find another example on her blog, like this one:

click to enlarge. I'd link back, but the original has been deleted.

Know how I know those "2 types of people" is not your idea, Miss Musing? You were 18, possibly 19, when cjane wrote that blog post and I find it hard to believe that any 18, possibly 19-year-old has that kind of perspective (my 18-ish-year-old perspective was really wrapped up in hoping I’d get tickets to the Downward Spiral Tour and showing up looking really cute for my Honors 200 course and the red-headed Canadian boy who sat next to me.) I was also in Courtney’s kitchen around the genesis of her idea and we have deeply discussed this topic over several years. I was able to place your paragraph within one whole second to this post:


The whole debacle is ridiculous. What’s worse? The plagiarism is merely a tool to build her reputation and capture her audience’s esteem. What’s even worse? She’s been contacted by a publishing company to possibly contribute to a book. Her plagiarism isn’t about what else she could add to the topic, or style, it is simple self-aggrandizement. And it’s frakking lazy.

Then we get to something really amusing:

click to enlarge. source also appears to have been deleted.

Yes, as you can see, this person had their own plagiarism issue with another blogger. Yet, after it happened to her, she plagiarized cjane at least twice. Oh, how delicious! Like rain on your wedding day! A free ride when you’ve already paid! Wait a minute…




UPDATE:

I found the original text to her plagiarized post:
"In the last of the sun, the Boyfriend and I took an evening walk. As the puppies navigated our way through the wide roads of our neighborhood, we quickly discovered that our evening activity proved unoriginal as we were greeted by neighbors who had the same idea.

"Hello Mr. and Mrs. Stamps," I said, passing an older couple. Having spent my childhood in this same neighborhood, I tend to know many of the home owners. The Boyfriend is always eager to make connections, so this leaves the him to rely on me for first-hand knowledge of background information as it pertains to our neighborhood history.

"Mr. Stamps is an Egyptologist and spent years working on the Theban Mapping Project at the American University in Cairo. Mrs. Stamps is a mother of five (doesn't she look so young?) and a painter. In fact, you admired her painting at the local gallery last time we were there."

The Boyfriend always listens, ear-tipped, as I talk under my breath. I wouldn't want our passing neighbors to know that I'm inclined to spill their personal resume to those within earshot.

We passed a Victorian home with a white picked fence outside.

"This is Mrs. Cronin's home." I pointed with my elbow (hands inside my coat pocket). "She was my first piano teacher."


We encountered houses with tangible memories spilling out the windows and doors. Homes of immaculate facades waiting to bloom with spring's floral offerings. We greet more neighbors who require my back-hand introductions.

"Hello Mr. and Mrs. Andover, " we all nod in salutation.

"Mr. Andover used to be the town mayor and Mrs. Andover volunteers as president of the Neighborhood Beautification Committee..." My voice like a spy.

"In fact, she helped me plant our garden this year. Now that the tulips are in bloom I really ought to invite her over for lunch and to see the garden."


As we rounded the corner home, we spotted a couple coming toward us.

"Hello." I said.

From my lack of words that followed, it became clear that I did not know them.



"That is Dr. and Mrs. Anderson." The Boyfriend returned the favor, matching my tone as we headed up the sidewalk. "He is a law school professor and she's a concert cellist..."

"Well played," I commended the Boyfriend."

You can read cjane's original here.

UPDATE
to the update here.

83 comments:

Cailean said...

This has jolted me out of lurking - I love your blog by the way. How irritating that someone would do that. I looked it up on her blog and the post is gone now of course. I wonder how many others she had to delete before being found out!!!!!

April said...

I don't get people. Why are they such jerks?

The whole book contribution thing, though. I'd be ready to start punching!

hannah said...

How I love you, Carina! That is very irritating.

rookie cookie said...

She is so original that she tells us all she likes the color pink. If that isn't originality, I don't know what is.

Something similar to this happened recently. Some weirdo started ripping off the way my sister edits my food pix. Bad idea. Megan ripped her apart.

amelia said...

Ha, I saw your tweet on this and was hoping you blogged about it too...I'm in luck! TOO FUNNY. And just...sad.

kiki said...

I'm going to plagiarize myself for a second time: Someone should make a "Plagiarizer" button to send to her so she can list it with her other "awards".

Wow! And she was asked to contribute to a book?! DAYAM! She crazy!

rookie cookie said...

As for the plagiarizer button, I am most certain Knuckleheaders would donate that.

creede said...

Hey I just wrote a post about plagiarism on my blog too, it seems someone was ripping off my friend cjane er um bjane and ......

ahh never mind.

That's Ms. Amy to You... said...

The plagiarist in question also appears to have ripped off Simple Mom's April 10th post. Again, why? Perhaps someone should school her on the finer points of differentiation between homage and rippin' someone off.

Jennifer said...

That makes me mad. How annoying!

Jenny said...

I choked on my banana bread when I read your comment, Cicada. I think that is going to be a phrase I repeat a lot to my sister.

I can't imagine having the nerve to try and pull off being cjane.

Nemesis said...

Dangit! Everyone beat me to the "ho-bag" slinging. Because seriously: HO. BAG.

dalene said...

I had no idea there was such a shortage of original thought in the blogosphere. Not to mention subtlety.

* sigh *

ClistyB said...

crazy
jerk
artist rape
ho-bag
.....
you all should be proud.

Sister Pottymouth said...

Ew. I can't believe someone would steal so blatantly!

citymama1 said...

Wow. That's crazy!

Cailean said...

I'm getting more irritated as I realize she has stolen from others. I have scrolled through her blog and found this VERY similar post to NieNie's. ORIGINAL: http://nieniedialogues.blogspot.com/2007/08/choices-by-nienie.html AND MISSMUSING'S: http://missmusing.blogspot.com/2009/02/choices.html

Anne-Marie said...

How embarassing-outed.

I found a post of mine copied last month. Word for word. Seriously!! My small blog audience will probably never notice.

But, to copy Courtney's...that's just embarassing.

Elizabeth said...

I looked around that blog for about 5 minutes, and a whole lot doesn't ring true. The whole thing appears to be either a big joke, or the product of a really troubled person who either doesn't know how to tell the truth, is deeply unhappy with her own life, or both.

Examples that raised red flags in within 5 minutes:
* This posting (http://missmusing.blogspot.com/2009/03/walk-in-park.html) includes photos purported to be taken one day on a walk in Central Park but they really don't look like they were taken with the same camera and, more obviously, one has trees with no leaves, and another has trees with plenty of leaves. Even accounting for different species of trees, there's no way they were taken the same day.
*In fact, really, none of the pictures look like they were taken with the same camera.
*Also, she calls Whole Foods a food mecca. And she supposedly spends time in NYC? No way she could still think WF is all that.

Annie said...

She has 198 suckers! I mean followers.

Sue said...

Pathetic.

Holly said...

people are so stupid. and i went to her blog earlier today from your twitter link and she is just annoying.

Melanie J said...

Crap. Now I'm really out of blog post ideas. I didn't know I was supposed to make my own thoughts up.

Natalie said...

Oh goodness. Like to copy CJane is heartless. How could you read that woman's blog about what she's done in the past year and be like "oh great material, I'll just copy and paste this!"

amelia said...

It's like a train wreck, I can't stop reading!

Those pictures are definitely stolen from somewhere. They're all different sizes, different cameras, different sharpness and color saturation. Ex: The yoga bag photo she uses in a bunch of her posts? Stolen from this Flickr site: http://www.flickr.com/photos/melisaur/2348476192/. And the pictures she has around her house? Looks like a completely different place in every picture.

Haha, she has a post about a commenter accusing her of being fake: http://missmusing.blogspot.com/2009/02/why-i-write_12.html

Nigel said...

Wow, word for word on the first paragraph. Then the rest of it was very similar to a post I recall about cjane taking the baby for a walk around the neighborhood.

Is it possible the whole blog is a much more subtle experiment in ticking people off a la "seriously so blessed"?

pflower10 said...

Has she been told that she's been found out?

I can't believe what she has done.

John Dent said...

Well I certainly hope all book offers are now off the table.

Shawn said...

Wow! I mean I never thought that people did that! Why?

I don't get it! I mean, its one thing to covet the following that someone has and to admire her talents as a writer, but what the heck?

She must have a terribly low self-esteem.

La Yen said...

Man, what do I have to DO to get plagiarized? Take off my shirt? Because I will, you know.

Laura said...

A couple weeks ago I found a recipe that was very obviously plagiarized from a popular website. I made a blog post about it and then emailed the perpetrator. Then one of her friends emailed me and told me the plagiarizer was really a nice person and they were sure they didn't mean to...

Then I was a chicken and I didn't want to be labeled a troll so I took down the post.

Your post has given me a fresh resolve to call out plagiarism. I wish bloggers understood the concept, if you appreciate a post, give it some link love--don't pretend it is all your own because the mighty internets will find out and we can sure be an ugly group of trolls!

Laura said...

I forgot my favorite part of reading her post about the book deal was "I was sure that it was either a) a joke or b) an offer directed at the wrong person." Going to guess the offer was directed at the wrong person!

Kalli Ko said...

yes, YES, YES!!!

i feel so vindicated.

people, blogging is not hard.

if your self esteem is so low and you looove comments to the point that if you don't get any you feel the urge throw yourself in front of a moving car (cough cough, mine) then perhaps i could pass along the name of a good shrink.

repeat after me, i'm smart enough, i'm good enough, and doggonit people like me.

except no one likes you right now.

sorry

haters (and posers) to the left

onnuh said...

I just had to delurk because this makes me so mad. I Googled text from just a few of her posts, and much of what she has is lifted from somewhere else:

1. http://missmusing.blogspot.com/2009/02/this-much-i-believe-to-be-true.html
FROM HERE:
http://www.lovefraud.com/blog/2008/06/23/lessons-after-the-sociopath-real-love-is-easy/

2. http://missmusing.blogspot.com/2009/02/full-circle.html AND http://missmusing.blogspot.com/2009/01/sundays.html
FROM HERE:
http://www.velveteenmind.com/velveteenmind/2009/01/sunday-serendipity-the-idea.html

3. http://missmusing.blogspot.com/2009/01/pieces.html
FROM HERE:
http://lotsofscotts.blogspot.com/2008/12/pieces.html?referer=sphere_search

4.http://missmusing.blogspot.com/2009/01/letter-to-next-president.html
FROM HERE:
http://momotot.blogspot.com/2009/01/inauguration-day-2009.html

5. http://missmusing.blogspot.com/2008/11/for-love-of-travel.html
FROM HERE:
http://newyorkerinlondon.blogspot.com/2009/03/bit-of-break.html

Mrs. Organic said...

Oh right, she just happened to have a similar experience and reread cjane's post and her own post came out word for word except she uses the word boyfriend...

Some people's children! Really.

April said...

What an insincere apology. Like when The Devil (not actually Satan, just an evil woman) basically called me a fat, fat, fatty, then told me she used to be a talent agent and I could be a model. Bull****! Either be sincere or don't apologize at all.

Also? La Yen's comment totally made me LOL!

Mrs. Flinger said...

Sorry, I hope someone hasn't already said this (I didn't read all the comments) but I thought it was funny that she couldn't even correct the typing. "so this leaves the him to rely on me for first-hand"

THE HIM? Because it was "This leaves Chup to rely on me for first-hand..."


I'm sorry your friend is dealing with this. Writing is art. It's not for stealing.

The Rookie said...

As an educator I find plagiarism rampant amongst my students. I nail them to the wall with their unethical actions (typically with a printed copy of the original author's work stapled onto their draft which has been superimposed with a fat red F). The shock on their faces (and in their parents' voices with the phone call that is sure to follow) is, well, shocking. You stole. You earn nothing. There is no grey area here.

Forget the old aphorism, "If you can't say anything nice, don't say anything at all"! The truth is that if you can't say anything ORIGINAL than shut your #$!@$ pie hole until you can!

Which leads me to a peevish blogger I've noticed swoop-swooping (stupidly) from a widely-followed blog. Take, as an example of her actions, this blog post (one of many stolen ideas):

http://sharandandrew.blogspot.com/2009/03/frame-risers.html

This blog's "author" (a term I use loosely) apparently thinks everything Nicole @ a little sussy touches is so golden (which, frankly, as a fan of sussy I must say that most of it is--the girl has some killer taste) that the wealth simply must be spread without giving any credit where credit is due. Credit, to, say, this ORIGINAL post:

http://nicolehill.blogspot.com/2009/02/frame-riser.html

Not the first nor will it be the last time the girl has done this.

onnuh said...

FYI, cJane and others, I commented on the other blogs from which I saw lifted material, giving the links of the similar posts on Miss Musing. Hopefully, you won't be the only one putting her in her place.

TX Girl said...

She bought the book and it now sits on her coffee table for others to read. Wow- I'm surprised she isn't hiding it, so her friends and family will not see her for the poser that she is.

Shameful.

dalene said...

Oh, and my typos were my own. I didn't steal them from anyone. I promise.

Annette Lyon said...

She's lame enough to steal from CJane and then spell her own revisions wrong. (A "picked" fence? Really?)

I don't see a book deal in her future. No publisher would touch someone with such a shady background.

Velveteen Mind Megan said...

Thanks for letting me know she hit at least one of my posts. I've reported her to Blogger but then brilliantly twittered it, so she'll probably just delete and then hit someone else.

I did take screengrabs, though.

Seriously, thank you for letting me know.

moodswingingmommy said...

Well done sleuths! Well done! How long before MM's blog is also set to private, I wonder?

PsychMamma said...

Wow. Browsing through her posts, many of them rang "warning bells" for me, but the Central Park photography really did it for me too (hat tip to Elizabeth above).

http://missmusing.blogspot.com/2009/03/walk-in-park.html

The first pic shows trees budding/with few leaves and the final pic shows full leaves. Her note at the bottom was the biggest flag:

"By the way--to those of you who have asked for the link to my Flickr photostream, I sincerely appreciate your interest and enthusiasm. However, it is currently set to private. If or when I do decide to make it public, I'll be sure to share the link here. Thank you for understanding."

Hmmm....me thinks something stinks. I'm betting very few (or none) of the photos are actually hers either.

Do you think her boyfriend's name is really Chup? Do you think she even HAS a boyfriend?? By obviously lying about some things, everything she writes comes into question.

Glad that she's getting called out on this.

KBM said...

Wow. Wow. Wow. I read the "comparison" posts side-by-side with Miss Musing's and it's just....really, really creepy. And not bright. So, there's my verdict. Creepy. And not bright. Why would you bother having a blog if you're just going to steal the thoughts, emotions and words of others?

Crazy Housewife said...

Found this post via twitter, and while I was browsing miss muses blog it suddenly got deleted.

"Sorry, the blog at missmusing.blogspot.com has been removed."

Sue said...

And I am bummed out that it's disappeared. I wanted to see it!

"/

PsychMamma said...

Miss Musing's entire blog has disappeared! Hmmmmm......

onnuh said...

Sue, I have a few more screen shots of her stuff on http://onnuh.com/?p=1119.

Loralee Choate said...

I hate plagiarism with the power of a thousand burning suns.

I had a plaigarist right before BlogHer last year. I would say 80% of this chick's blog was stolen. (My readers were very...um...dedicated when it came to tracking her down.)

I published every name/alias that could be found on her and you would not BELIEVE the crap that has surfaced about her. She is even on "anti-scam internet dating sites".

BTW? She has a new blog. And guess what? Yup. Reeks of stolen material.

These people do not ever learn.

P.S. I'm glad that she took her blog down because Cafe Mom (where I heard this one was hosted) SUCKED to work with regarding stolen content. I had ROCK SOLID PROOF that page after page was stolen by her BUT because I (and my other readers who contacted them) weren't the original author they refused to do anything about it and gave me the internet equivilant of "too bad, so sad".

They blow in my opinion. Almost more than the person who stole it in the first place.

Millie said...

I READ that last post of c jane's on her BLOG not a month ago! It's totally recognizable! Did Miss Musing think her readers were completely stupid?

Here from C-dub. :)

ClistyB said...

MM's boyfriend's name was Kurt.

Wiggs (The Beholder) said...

Vomit. My ma is a novelist and in our family plagiarism is the worst form of thievery and disgustingness one person can do to another without any physical assault. Despicable.

Heffalump said...

I think that the best thing for Blogger to have done, rather than just deleting her blog, would have been to put a single post up in place of it telling everyone that the blog was taken down for stealing content, and then every one of her readers would know about it. Now she will probably just get a different email address and start fresh stealing someone else's stuff.

♥Lucky♥Holly♥ said...

Cjane is most definetly inspiring as a writer. But hot dog don't people have any scruples? WORD FOR WORD? What the heck!??

Thanks for outing this person!

x Australia

Heather said...

Thanks for the link. When I wrote cjane about the plagiarizer I saw back in March she said, "This is definitely the first time this sort of thing has happened." So glad she has The Board to handle what was most definitely NOT the first time it had happened.

Many of the people linking over from you have mentioned that they wished they could see the plagiarized version of cjane from the blog I found, so I dug it up out of my reader and blogged it here: http://theheathershow.blogspot.com/2009/04/for-all-yall-comin-for-details-on-cjane.html. The copy is an entertaining read, if nothing else.

M said...

Apologies if this has already been noted (only scanned the comments) - but isn't the post "Imitation is the Sincerest Form of Flattery" stolen from Tertia / So Close?? I have never read the MissMusing blog but I KNOW I have read that post somewhere before. How ironic that she is stealing a post about stolen posts!! Amazing.

Beth said...

aside from all of the perfectly obvious reasons why one should not plagerize, it is fundamentally, just idiotic. the blogging community is one in which you SHARE thoughts and ideas. share being the key word here. i am often inspired by someone's project or prose, and if it then prompts me to give my two cents, i appropriately site the origins of my brainstorm. for example, "sally was talking about the truly wonderous miracles of spanx on her blog the other day, which got me to thinking...why can't clothes just come with them already sewn in? it would save money and the hastle. wouldn't that be lovely?"
see, not hard at all. and this sharing of ideas makes way for your OWN thoughts, feelings, and ideas to surface. plagarism just sucks!

Artfulife said...

Has anyone brought up the fact that she had a cartoon for a picture? "She" could possibly be a "he". Haahaa. But for real, she knew what she was doing the whole time. That's probably why she couldn't post a picture of her true self. I don't think she probably knows who her "true self" is.

Sinclair said...

How naive of me to have been surprised by this phenomenon. I would NEVER have thought someone would copy ENTIRE posts!! I will have to be on the lookout...

I love cjane's blog, and yours as well.

Bridget said...

As someone who enjoyed Miss Musing's blog until a few hours ago when I learned that it was all fake, I am stunned, not to mention sickened by her actions.

I am truly sorry to all of those who have had their work plagiarized. I would hope that someone would tell me if my work were being duplicated without permission.

I feel sorry for someone who feels the need to steal like that. It is absolutely inexcusable.

Brooke said...

I love cjane's writing.

Plagerism is wrong. It is dishonest.

But I don't think that a blog flog is that great either.

i i eee said...

How is stealing an idea an less of a crime than stealing any tangible object?

If someone steals my big, shiny flat screen TV, is it in bad taste to blog about it? Am I being impolite by getting upset that someone stole it from me? Or is it best for me to just say, "Oh that person saw how much I was enjoying my TV, it's so flattering that they stole it from me! Now they can be just like me--or how I used to be, by having my TV in their possession! I feel so special!"

I cry artist rape because that's what it is. I become even more upset when people don't seem to think it's a big deal.

Laurie said...

I didn't see if anyone said this or not, since I didn't read all the comments (sorry), but I use www.copyscape.com to find out if i've been copied. it's a great source and has helped me MANY times as i've been copied for years (on lampworking information etc). It's no fun, that's fur sure. They say it's a form of flattery but after a while it really pisses you off.

So glad the blog has been removed. :)

Cafe Johnsonia said...
This post has been removed by the author.
Brooke said...

I agree the person should be outed. I think it is a huge deal. Especially if she was making money off of it, or could have.
By blog flog I am referring to the name calling, the unchristian aspect of kick em while their down.

Amber said...

I am just disgusted. I read her blog all the time and loved it.

i i eee said...

Brooke, if you read this post closely, you'll see that Carina is not calling Miss Musing a string of horrible names. Carina is being quite gracious if you ask me.

I on the other hand, have freely called Miss Musing a few harsh words. Call it "unChristian" if you must, but when I turn on my computer I don't sign an agreement everyday saying everything I do online is going to please my fellow Christians. Feel free to judge me for my venom. I don't care--especially when I'm being judged from an anonymous source. This means nothing to me.

But don't bash Carina for letting her readers think and speak for themselves. And the whole it's "unChristian" argument is just downright irritating. Are all of your actions perfect? Can you say everything you do or say or think is unto Christ? What makes you the Christian Police?

Elisa said...

Shameless. Pathetic. Idiotic. So many adjectives come to mind, none of them even remotely flattering. She most definitely doesn't deserve a book deal.

Jennifer said...

Oh please, I agree that bringing in the "unchristian" argument is pretty annoying.

Miss Musing, and anyone else who copies blogs, deserves a lot more than getting their blog taken down. She got off easy, if you ask me.

No Cool Story said...

kiki made me :D

"Someone should make "Plagiarizer" button to send to her so she can list it with her other "awards".

Bwahahaha!

No Cool Story said...

Oh snap! Totally busted.
BOOOO.

carrie said...

Everytime I hear about something like this, it makes me want to go private.

Not that my writing is the best out there, but people will steal anything and I hate that thought.

You're a good friend to point this out.

Sharon said...

Unfortunately in the day of anonymity on the internet, the line between what is right and wrong has become too easily obscured. I experienced this same kind of blantant plagerism when my husband and I were certified for adoption. There were a couple families in our same agency (LDSFS) who copied pages from our adoption website almost verbatim. One of which copied our birthmother letter! It was appalling to me, especially because they were not completely anonymous.

Copying people's work has become more and more common place. My husband sees that every year as a university prof. It's unfortunate that integrity is not cherished more in our society.

Rebekah said...

I just hopped over here from Joy's blog at Big Time Fancy... what a rotten, rotten thing for someone to do.

Does anyone know what publishing house asked her about a book contribution? I'd send them a word or two.

insomniaclolita said...

As her reader, I feel duped. Many people are affected, she even met some of us. It's hurtful when it extends personally too. :(

CAC muffin said...

oh my gosh i can't believe any would do this or think it was even ok to do this! I'm shocked! If one is doing it there must be others! thats horrible!

ceecee said...

I followed your blog from Lolita... and O.M.G. I can not believe Miss Musing did that. I truly enjoyed her blog and thought everything she wrote was real - I should have known better that her "boyfriend" was too good to be true!

I've never read cjane's blog at all, and when I compared the posts, my mouth dropped...

Miss Musing is no longer on blogger.com

I need to take her off my Blog List...

spear-britney said...

OH my, the audacity of some folks. Thanks for calling them out!

amyinbc said...

Well feel flattered first of all, she obviously felt your blog and writings were REALLY good and worth stealing! But yes, that would upset me greatly to see someone else stealing my experiences and posts. Glad to see she has high tailed it and ran! Good riddance.

I have tried to email your sister for support on her surgery but my email bounced. Is there an email we can send our best wishes to? Thanks, Amy

amynm3@gmail.com

Christa Jeanne said...

Oh, WOW. That's awful! So ridiculously blatant. As a writer, I bristle at this. Stealing someone's intellectual property is so not cool!

eve said...

Wow. One of the ironic things is, the Miss Whatever blog even had a copyright button on her own blog--and after stealing from others! Too bad her life and imaginations is so boring that she needed to take stories from others.